It's People
"I think we need to be open to the idea that the client can be wrong."
I wish I had said it that way. Instead, my response was dripping with sarcasm. My point got made. What I didn't realize was how much damage I'd just done to my team in the process of making it.
This was a pattern in my first real leadership role. My job was to provide technical direction for the team, but I was slowly losing the people I was supposed to lead.
Thankfully, my team told me. The teammate I'd been sarcastic with said something I've never forgotten: "I like you. I just want to be your friend. The way you speak to me sometimes in arguments makes me feel like you don't want that."
That was one of the most helpful pieces of feedback I've ever received, and it was a pivot point in my career. It taught me that being correct doesn't matter if you lose the ability to communicate with the people you work with. I did want to be friends with this person, so repairing the relationship was in my interest in that respect. But what I underappreciated at the time was the real impact my behavior had on the team's ability to deliver results.
Whether your team is killing it or having a hard time, at the end of the day: It's people.
The claim
Here's what I now believe: how you make people feel matters more than any technical skill, any knowledge, any strategy, idea, or vision you possess.
Technical things are real, and they matter. But they're not enough to overcome more human-based dysfunctions of a team. Brilliant strategy can't work if the team feels less-than. Most people don't do their best work under duress, and so a fundamentally healthy team culture is a prerequisite for winning as a technology team.
Why it's true
Nothing of great impact gets done alone. Every project is run by people who choose, every day, how much of themselves to put into it.
People hide problems from leaders they're afraid of, and they surface them early to leaders they trust. People stay quiet in the meeting where their input would have mattered. People comply instead of committing. People quiet quit, and stop trying. People do not go the extra mile, and the extra mile is what is needed to build and sustain large technology projects!
So if teams can't figure out how to motivate their people, make them feel safe, and create a context where their people will go the extra mile, there are tough roads ahead. And it's the responsibility of the leader to ensure this is done.
That's the part I got wrong back then. I thought my job was to be right. My job was to make it safe.
The turn
When I came on board to lead a team in my next assignment, I made a decision: team building would be a deliberate practice, not something I hoped would happen on its own.
I leaned on two frameworks. The Five Dysfunctions of a Team puts trust at the base of everything, because without it, teams can't have honest conflict, commit to decisions, or hold each other accountable. Kim Scott's Radical Candor gave me the balance I'd been missing: care personally, and challenge directly. I'd been doing the second without the first.
And I set myself a simple rule. In every interaction, my first concern was to make the other person feel appreciated, good, and smart.
The surprise
I expected culture work to cost some time and energy. I was shocked at how little was needed to get some amazing results. Teammates were starving for an opportunity to talk about the team's culture. I quickly noticed that productivity gains were happening downstream of the culture conversations and improvements.
When people have better conversations, they create better solutions.
The reason, I think, is that most people are intrinsically motivated to do well, and to support one another. You don't have to manufacture motivation. When you encourage people, they naturally align with the goals of the team. Most of the work of leadership is removing whatever is suppressing what's already there. For me, early on, that was me. In my next role, I wasn't the problem anymore.
"But skills still matter"
Of course they do. You can't be kind and incompetent and expect it to work. Skill is what gets you into the room. But once you're in the room, how people feel about working with you decides what happens next.
And this isn't about avoiding hard conversations. Making people feel valued is exactly what makes candor work. Hard feedback from someone who you respect is a gift. The same feedback from someone you don't is brushed off. So don't bother digging in technically where you haven't yet established trust.
What it looks like in practice
- Praise people frequently and publicly
- Be generally positive, happy, and optimistic
- Foreground individuals in good circumstances, foreground impacts in bad ones
- Say out loud that you care about your teammates
- Protect your teammates when issues arise
Closing
Strip away the frameworks and the tools, and the job comes down to this: leaders owe their teams an environment where people feel safe, motivated, and willing to give more than the minimum. A team that can't build that is in for a hard road, and building it isn't optional or something to delegate. It belongs to the leader.
I learned that by getting it wrong first. The strategy was never the hard part.
It's people.